|
CONLANG Archives
|
CONLANG@LISTSERV.BROWN.EDU
|
|
|
|
I moved this reply to a different thread because, clearly, this doesn't have anything
to do with the continually evolving saga of the amicus brief.
I will only say, however, that it would seem the LCS is being taken seriously in this
thing. After all, if Paramount are bitching about the "timeliness" of the brief, and
are willing to pay their legal team to bother to contest the brief, then they are at
least aware of its contents are are viewing the LCS as an Authority. Chapeau!
As usual, the following are my opinions only...
Before moving on to replies, I would note that no one has yet (as of this writing)
mentioned the ethics of imposing a constructed language on an innocent third party.
Here of course I mean those intrepid few who have chosen, not just to teach a few
words or phrases, but rather to make their kids bilingual Klingon speakers or what
have you.
Any comments on this kind of experimentation? Does anyone discriminate between
art- and aux- as far as this ethical issue is concerned?
I hold that there is a distinction to be made between teaching a child an artlang vs
an auxlang as his cradle language (either in conjunction with or to the exclusion
of any natural language). Given the age & maturity of (in particular) E-o as a language
& given its nature as an auxiliary / second language, I find its use as a second cradle
language much less objectionable than the more reprehensible (ab)use of Klingon or
Sindarin or an individual glossopoet using his own creation in this way.
Jim Henry <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> Galen Buttitta <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
>
> > Well, as to cultural appropriation: Pirahã has evidential morphemes and may be
>
> I am not sure what the boundaries of cultural appropriation are, or
> whether I am sure that it is always and inherently wrong; but I'm
> pretty sure taking one feature from a language (which probably isn't
> unique to that language) is not cultural appropriation.
I would agree with this. I actually rather despise the whole concept of
"cultural appropriation" as an inherently evil thing. After all, how would
modern Western culture have evolved at all if "we" (or our cultural
ancestors in France & England) had not appropriated Greek democracy &
philosophy, Roman architecture, Germanic mythology, Hebrew religion
and ethics? And all this without ever asking the Greeks or the Jews or the
Italians whether or not they wouldn't mind? You see, humans are naturally
inquisitive, natural mimics. If we see something that works, we add it to
the store of what we know already. Kids do this naturally when they play
games; adults do this at work. Languages borrow / steal from one another
and so do cultures. It's no different for an artist making up his own culture
or language. The only difference is that the process is more transparent.
It's a nicety to leave some kind of working notes behind you as you work,
but not a requirement and not a sign of cultural imperialism or pillage if
you use a language feature from somewhere and don't credit it. Heck, if I
had to go back now and create an annotated credit list of cultures,
languages and people that inspired me, I'd probably have to spend the
rest of my life combing through every little turn of phrase, every piece of
cultural or linguistic apparatus. Sure, some homages are pretty
transparent, but others are now opaque even to me!
Art thus risks becoming a drudge of annotational paperwork rather than a
celebration of human ingenuity and creativity and universality.
That said, I do agree that cultural appropriation is an issue (the Nazi
appropriation & perversion of cultural symbols comes to mind); but
as far as the individual glossopoet is concerned, the morality and
ethics here really come to the balance of "your right to express
yourself (via making a language)" vs "my right to be culturally
outraged (by my perception of theft of cultural heritage)". At least in
the US, the right to freedom of self expression, and in particular via the
written word, is held more sacred than the right of groups or individuals
to prevent the use of cultural properties.
A conscientious glossopoet would, I think, be unlikely to seek to harm
a whole culture or any individual members of it through outright theft
of such cultural property. It's one thing for art to imitate life, but quite
another for it to slavishly copy it! That said, I think that our works of
art ought to be subject to open criticism -- if I take an Australian
language and relex it, and use it in a story where I've taken Australian
religion and culture and copied them, I think I could rightfully expect
to be lambasted for the effort. On the other hand, if I take certain
chosen aspects of those languages & cultures and weave them in
with other threads into a completely different and new tapestry, even
thought some patterns within it might be recogniseable, then I don't
think the Australians would have an argument, and the art could
simply be criticised for its own self rather than as a copy-n-paste job.
> Taking lots of features from the same natlang, especially if the speakers'
> conculture is also based largely on the culture of the natlang's
> speakers, might be cultural appropriation. Whether that's wrong is
> another issue,
Yes. I think this would largely depend on how pervasive and how specific
the appropriation is. Language features are largely covered by ANADEW,
as we already know. If a natural language currently does X, then there
are now, or were at one time, or will be in future a dozen more languages
that also do X. But it also depends on what the artist dóes with that
material. Is it a blatant rip-off, or is it artfully rewoven into something
new?
> which at least partly depends on whether the natlang's
> speakers object and how the conlanger responds to their objections.
> (Many Australian aborigines apparently object strongly to their
> religion being used as mythological background in fantasy novels.
> Attribution isn't the issue, permission is. Some other cultures, not
> so much.)
I don't remember Andres Serrano asking permission to toss a crucifix
into a cup of piss. I don't remember the US Government asking permission
when the National Endowment for the Arts sponsored organization
Southeastern Center for Contemporary Art awarded him a medal for his
good aim.
I'm not debating whether or not Serrano's work is art or not -- I do hold,
however, that he does not need anyone's permission to do art. Just do it
and let the chips fall where they may.
> Robert Dessaix keeps his conlang secret, even to its true name (he
> calls it "K" when he occasionally talks about it). Javant Biarujia
> kept his conlang secret for a long time, but eventually published it.
> I kept my gjâ-zym-byn secret for the first couple of years, but
> eventually published some of its grammar, and then more, including the
> lexicon.
Most of mine are kept secret. I've only ever "published" the grammar
to Kerno (but that because of its nature as part of a group project in the
public domain). As I see it, my interest is in expressing something deep inside
in a language other than English and thus in having to discover and
record that language other than English. If someone is crazy enough to
want to learn it, well, that's their issue. It's not my job to provide lessons
and tutorials!
And Rosta wrote:
> For me this is not a matter specific to conlangs. Platonic things (i.e. ideas)
> cannot justly by owned. They're like natural resources in that respect.
Some platonic things, I would agree, would be improper to consider ownable.
A life-saving technology, an improved way of farming. Others, no they can
indeed be justly owned.
Since we're talking of languages, I would agree here in terms of a natural
language.
A natural language, be it English or ancient Greek, is the property of a
community of speakers and ought by natural law be shared with anyone
willing to learn it (and thus become a naturalised member of that community,
or at least someone needing to interact with it).
However, a *constructed* language is no longer a mere natural resource
but is now a piece of wrought art. The glossopoet has taken the natural
resources of human language and has, through secret alchemies made them
into a new creation, a thing belonging soully to its creator. It is solely at the
discretion of the glossopoet whether or not to share any part of it. It's like
your own inner song or your soul name. You do not share these things
lightly and, no, society as a whole does not have a claim on these platonic
things.
> But it is in society's interests to find a non-ownership-based way to
> remunerate discoverers of natural resources and discoverers (or 'inventors')
> of platonic things. I assume that ownership of X entails the right to deny
> others usufruct of X.
No argument re actual natural resources. Water, minerals, food sources.
I would amend this only by saying that the creator of the platonic thing in
question -- the glossopoet -- must be willing to hand over that thing. If he
wishes to keep it a secret, or wishes to keep its inner workings to himself,
that's his own business. Also keep in mind that this particular platonic thing
is a work of art, not a cure for cancer or a recipe for transparent aluminium!
No one in society actually benefits from knowing or truly loses anything by
not knowing how Queranaran works. If I knew how to cure cancer, I would
feel morally and ethically obligated to share that knowledge. I feel and indeed
accept no such obligations to share more of my languages and worlds than I
am willing to make public.
|
|
|
|
|
Archives |
October 2024, Week 2 October 2024, Week 1 September 2024, Week 5 September 2024, Week 4 September 2024, Week 3 September 2024, Week 2 September 2024, Week 1 August 2024, Week 5 August 2024, Week 4 August 2024, Week 3 August 2024, Week 2 August 2024, Week 1 July 2024, Week 5 July 2024, Week 4 July 2024, Week 3 July 2024, Week 2 July 2024, Week 1 June 2024, Week 5 June 2024, Week 4 June 2024, Week 3 June 2024, Week 2 June 2024, Week 1 May 2024, Week 5 May 2024, Week 4 May 2024, Week 3 May 2024, Week 2 May 2024, Week 1 April 2024, Week 5 April 2024, Week 4 April 2024, Week 3 April 2024, Week 2 April 2024, Week 1 March 2024, Week 5 March 2024, Week 4 March 2024, Week 3 March 2024, Week 2 March 2024, Week 1 February 2024, Week 5 February 2024, Week 4 February 2024, Week 3 February 2024, Week 2 February 2024, Week 1 January 2024, Week 5 January 2024, Week 4 January 2024, Week 3 January 2024, Week 2 January 2024, Week 1 December 2023, Week 5 December 2023, Week 4 December 2023, Week 3 December 2023, Week 2 December 2023, Week 1 November 2023, Week 5 November 2023, Week 4 November 2023, Week 3 November 2023, Week 2 November 2023, Week 1 October 2023, Week 5 October 2023, Week 4 October 2023, Week 3 October 2023, Week 2 October 2023, Week 1 September 2023, Week 5 September 2023, Week 4 September 2023, Week 3 September 2023, Week 2 September 2023, Week 1 August 2023, Week 5 August 2023, Week 4 August 2023, Week 3 August 2023, Week 2 August 2023, Week 1 July 2023, Week 5 July 2023, Week 4 July 2023, Week 3 July 2023, Week 2 July 2023, Week 1 June 2023, Week 5 June 2023, Week 4 June 2023, Week 3 June 2023, Week 2 June 2023, Week 1 May 2023, Week 5 May 2023, Week 4 May 2023, Week 3 May 2023, Week 2 May 2023, Week 1 April 2023, Week 5 April 2023, Week 4 April 2023, Week 3 April 2023, Week 2 April 2023, Week 1 March 2023, Week 5 March 2023, Week 4 March 2023, Week 3 March 2023, Week 2 March 2023, Week 1 February 2023, Week 4 February 2023, Week 3 February 2023, Week 2 February 2023, Week 1 January 2023, Week 5 January 2023, Week 4 January 2023, Week 3 January 2023, Week 2 January 2023, Week 1 December 2022, Week 5 December 2022, Week 4 December 2022, Week 3 December 2022, Week 2 December 2022, Week 1 November 2022, Week 5 November 2022, Week 4 November 2022, Week 3 November 2022, Week 2 November 2022, Week 1 October 2022, Week 5 October 2022, Week 4 October 2022, Week 3 October 2022, Week 2 October 2022, Week 1 September 2022, Week 4 September 2022, Week 3 September 2022, Week 2 September 2022, Week 1 August 2022, Week 5 August 2022, Week 4 August 2022, Week 3 August 2022, Week 2 August 2022, Week 1 July 2022, Week 5 July 2022, Week 4 July 2022, Week 3 July 2022, Week 2 July 2022, Week 1 June 2022, Week 5 June 2022, Week 4 June 2022, Week 3 June 2022, Week 2 June 2022, Week 1 May 2022, Week 5 May 2022, Week 4 May 2022, Week 3 May 2022, Week 2 May 2022, Week 1 April 2022, Week 5 April 2022, Week 4 April 2022, Week 3 April 2022, Week 2 April 2022, Week 1 March 2022, Week 5 March 2022, Week 4 March 2022, Week 3 March 2022, Week 2 March 2022, Week 1 February 2022, Week 4 February 2022, Week 3 February 2022, Week 2 February 2022, Week 1 January 2022, Week 5 January 2022, Week 4 January 2022, Week 3 January 2022, Week 2 January 2022, Week 1 December 2021, Week 5 December 2021, Week 4 December 2021, Week 3 December 2021, Week 2 December 2021, Week 1 November 2021, Week 5 November 2021, Week 4 November 2021, Week 3 November 2021, Week 2 November 2021, Week 1 October 2021, Week 5 October 2021, Week 4 October 2021, Week 3 October 2021, Week 2 October 2021, Week 1 September 2021, Week 5 September 2021, Week 4 September 2021, Week 3 September 2021, Week 2 September 2021, Week 1 August 2021, Week 4 August 2021, Week 3 August 2021, Week 2 August 2021, Week 1 July 2021, Week 5 July 2021, Week 4 July 2021, Week 3 July 2021, Week 2 July 2021, Week 1 June 2021, Week 5 June 2021, Week 4 June 2021, Week 3 June 2021, Week 2 June 2021, Week 1 May 2021, Week 5 May 2021, Week 4 May 2021, Week 3 May 2021, Week 2 May 2021, Week 1 April 2021, Week 5 April 2021, Week 4 April 2021, Week 3 April 2021, Week 2 April 2021, Week 1 March 2021, Week 5 March 2021, Week 4 March 2021, Week 3 March 2021, Week 2 March 2021, Week 1 February 2021, Week 4 February 2021, Week 3 February 2021, Week 2 February 2021, Week 1 January 2021, Week 5 January 2021, Week 4 January 2021, Week 3 January 2021, Week 2 January 2021, Week 1 December 2020, Week 5 December 2020, Week 4 December 2020, Week 3 December 2020, Week 2 December 2020, Week 1 November 2020, Week 5 November 2020, Week 4 November 2020, Week 3 November 2020, Week 2 November 2020, Week 1 October 2020, Week 5 October 2020, Week 4 October 2020, Week 3 October 2020, Week 2 October 2020, Week 1 September 2020, Week 5 September 2020, Week 4 September 2020, Week 3 September 2020, Week 2 September 2020, Week 1 August 2020, Week 5 August 2020, Week 4 August 2020, Week 3 August 2020, Week 2 August 2020, Week 1 July 2020, Week 5 July 2020, Week 4 July 2020, Week 3 July 2020, Week 2 July 2020, Week 1 June 2020, Week 4 June 2020, Week 3 June 2020, Week 2 June 2020, Week 1 May 2020, Week 5 May 2020, Week 4 May 2020, Week 3 May 2020, Week 2 May 2020, Week 1 April 2020, Week 5 April 2020, Week 4 April 2020, Week 3 April 2020, Week 2 April 2020, Week 1 March 2020, Week 5 March 2020, Week 4 March 2020, Week 3 March 2020, Week 2 March 2020, Week 1 February 2020, Week 5 February 2020, Week 4 February 2020, Week 3 February 2020, Week 2 February 2020, Week 1 January 2020, Week 5 January 2020, Week 4 January 2020, Week 3 January 2020, Week 2 January 2020, Week 1 December 2019, Week 5 December 2019, Week 4 December 2019, Week 3 December 2019, Week 2 December 2019, Week 1 November 2019, Week 5 November 2019, Week 4 November 2019, Week 3 November 2019, Week 2 November 2019, Week 1 October 2019, Week 5 October 2019, Week 4 October 2019, Week 3 October 2019, Week 2 October 2019, Week 1 September 2019, Week 5 September 2019, Week 4 September 2019, Week 3 September 2019, Week 2 September 2019, Week 1 August 2019, Week 5 August 2019, Week 4 August 2019, Week 3 August 2019, Week 2 August 2019, Week 1 July 2019, Week 5 July 2019, Week 4 July 2019, Week 3 July 2019, Week 2 July 2019, Week 1 June 2019, Week 5 June 2019, Week 4 June 2019, Week 3 June 2019, Week 2 June 2019, Week 1 May 2019, Week 5 May 2019, Week 4 May 2019, Week 3 May 2019, Week 2 May 2019, Week 1 April 2019, Week 5 April 2019, Week 4 April 2019, Week 3 April 2019, Week 2 April 2019, Week 1 March 2019, Week 5 March 2019, Week 4 March 2019, Week 3 March 2019, Week 2 March 2019, Week 1 February 2019, Week 4 February 2019, Week 3 February 2019, Week 2 February 2019, Week 1 January 2019, Week 5 January 2019, Week 4 January 2019, Week 3 January 2019, Week 2 January 2019, Week 1 December 2018, Week 5 December 2018, Week 4 December 2018, Week 3 December 2018, Week 2 December 2018, Week 1 November 2018, Week 5 November 2018, Week 4 November 2018, Week 3 November 2018, Week 2 November 2018, Week 1 October 2018, Week 5 October 2018, Week 4 October 2018, Week 3 October 2018, Week 2 October 2018, Week 1 September 2018, Week 5 September 2018, Week 4 September 2018, Week 3 September 2018, Week 2 September 2018, Week 1 August 2018, Week 5 August 2018, Week 4 August 2018, Week 3 August 2018, Week 2 August 2018, Week 1 July 2018, Week 5 July 2018, Week 4 July 2018, Week 3 July 2018, Week 2 July 2018, Week 1 June 2018, Week 5 June 2018, Week 4 June 2018, Week 3 June 2018, Week 2 June 2018, Week 1 May 2018, Week 5 May 2018, Week 4 May 2018, Week 3 May 2018, Week 2 May 2018, Week 1 April 2018, Week 5 April 2018, Week 4 April 2018, Week 3 April 2018, Week 2 April 2018, Week 1 March 2018, Week 5 March 2018, Week 4 March 2018, Week 3 March 2018, Week 2 March 2018, Week 1 February 2018, Week 4 February 2018, Week 3 February 2018, Week 2 February 2018, Week 1 January 2018, Week 5 January 2018, Week 4 January 2018, Week 3 January 2018, Week 2 January 2018, Week 1 December 2017, Week 5 December 2017, Week 4 December 2017, Week 3 December 2017, Week 2 December 2017, Week 1 November 2017, Week 5 November 2017, Week 4 November 2017, Week 3 November 2017, Week 2 November 2017, Week 1 October 2017, Week 5 October 2017, Week 4 October 2017, Week 3 October 2017, Week 2 October 2017, Week 1 September 2017, Week 5 September 2017, Week 4 September 2017, Week 3 September 2017, Week 2 September 2017, Week 1 August 2017, Week 5 August 2017, Week 4 August 2017, Week 3 August 2017, Week 2 August 2017, Week 1 July 2017, Week 5 July 2017, Week 4 July 2017, Week 3 July 2017, Week 2 July 2017, Week 1 June 2017, Week 5 June 2017, Week 4 June 2017, Week 3 June 2017, Week 2 June 2017, Week 1 May 2017, Week 5 May 2017, Week 4 May 2017, Week 3 May 2017, Week 2 May 2017, Week 1 April 2017, Week 5 April 2017, Week 4 April 2017, Week 3 April 2017, Week 2 April 2017, Week 1 March 2017, Week 5 March 2017, Week 4 March 2017, Week 3 March 2017, Week 2 March 2017, Week 1 February 2017, Week 4 February 2017, Week 3 February 2017, Week 2 February 2017, Week 1 January 2017, Week 4 January 2017, Week 3 January 2017, Week 2 January 2017, Week 1 December 2016, Week 5 December 2016, Week 4 December 2016, Week 3 December 2016, Week 2 December 2016, Week 1 November 2016, Week 5 November 2016, Week 4 November 2016, Week 3 November 2016, Week 2 November 2016, Week 1 October 2016, Week 5 October 2016, Week 4 October 2016, Week 3 October 2016, Week 2 October 2016, Week 1 September 2016, Week 5 September 2016, Week 4 September 2016, Week 3 September 2016, Week 2 September 2016, Week 1 August 2016, Week 5 August 2016, Week 4 August 2016, Week 3 August 2016, Week 2 August 2016, Week 1 July 2016, Week 5 July 2016, Week 4 July 2016, Week 3 July 2016, Week 2 July 2016, Week 1 June 2016, Week 5 June 2016, Week 4 June 2016, Week 3 June 2016, Week 2 June 2016, Week 1 May 2016, Week 5 May 2016, Week 4 May 2016, Week 3 May 2016, Week 2 May 2016, Week 1 April 2016, Week 5 April 2016, Week 4 April 2016, Week 3 April 2016, Week 2 April 2016, Week 1 March 2016, Week 5 March 2016, Week 4 March 2016, Week 3 March 2016, Week 2 March 2016, Week 1 February 2016, Week 5 February 2016, Week 4 February 2016, Week 3 February 2016, Week 2 February 2016, Week 1 January 2016, Week 5 January 2016, Week 4 January 2016, Week 3 January 2016, Week 2 January 2016, Week 1 December 2015, Week 5 December 2015, Week 4 December 2015, Week 3 December 2015, Week 2 December 2015, Week 1 November 2015, Week 5 November 2015, Week 4 November 2015, Week 3 November 2015, Week 2 November 2015, Week 1 October 2015, Week 5 October 2015, Week 4 October 2015, Week 3 October 2015, Week 2 October 2015, Week 1 September 2015, Week 5 September 2015, Week 4 September 2015, Week 3 September 2015, Week 2 September 2015, Week 1 August 2015, Week 5 August 2015, Week 4 August 2015, Week 3 August 2015, Week 2 August 2015, Week 1 July 2015, Week 5 July 2015, Week 4 July 2015, Week 3 July 2015, Week 2 July 2015, Week 1 June 2015, Week 5 June 2015, Week 4 June 2015, Week 3 June 2015, Week 2 June 2015, Week 1 May 2015, Week 5 May 2015, Week 4 May 2015, Week 3 May 2015, Week 2 May 2015, Week 1 April 2015, Week 5 April 2015, Week 4 April 2015, Week 3 April 2015, Week 2 April 2015, Week 1 March 2015, Week 5 March 2015, Week 4 March 2015, Week 3 March 2015, Week 2 March 2015, Week 1 February 2015, Week 4 February 2015, Week 3 February 2015, Week 2 February 2015, Week 1 January 2015, Week 5 January 2015, Week 4 January 2015, Week 3 January 2015, Week 2 January 2015, Week 1 December 2014, Week 5 December 2014, Week 4 December 2014, Week 3 December 2014, Week 2 December 2014, Week 1 November 2014, Week 5 November 2014, Week 4 November 2014, Week 3 November 2014, Week 2 November 2014, Week 1 October 2014, Week 5 October 2014, Week 4 October 2014, Week 3 October 2014, Week 2 October 2014, Week 1 September 2014, Week 5 September 2014, Week 4 September 2014, Week 3 September 2014, Week 2 September 2014, Week 1 August 2014, Week 5 August 2014, Week 4 August 2014, Week 3 August 2014, Week 2 August 2014, Week 1 July 2014, Week 5 July 2014, Week 4 July 2014, Week 3 July 2014, Week 2 July 2014, Week 1 June 2014, Week 5 June 2014, Week 4 June 2014, Week 3 June 2014, Week 2 June 2014, Week 1 May 2014, Week 5 May 2014, Week 4 May 2014, Week 3 May 2014, Week 2 May 2014, Week 1 April 2014, Week 5 April 2014, Week 4 April 2014, Week 3 April 2014, Week 2 April 2014, Week 1 March 2014, Week 5 March 2014, Week 4 March 2014, Week 3 March 2014, Week 2 March 2014, Week 1 February 2014, Week 4 February 2014, Week 3 February 2014, Week 2 February 2014, Week 1 January 2014, Week 5 January 2014, Week 4 January 2014, Week 3 January 2014, Week 2 January 2014, Week 1 December 2013, Week 5 December 2013, Week 4 December 2013, Week 3 December 2013, Week 2 December 2013, Week 1 November 2013, Week 5 November 2013, Week 4 November 2013, Week 3 November 2013, Week 2 November 2013, Week 1 October 2013, Week 5 October 2013, Week 4 October 2013, Week 3 October 2013, Week 2 October 2013, Week 1 September 2013, Week 5 September 2013, Week 4 September 2013, Week 3 September 2013, Week 2 September 2013, Week 1 August 2013, Week 5 August 2013, Week 4 August 2013, Week 3 August 2013, Week 2 August 2013, Week 1 July 2013, Week 5 July 2013, Week 4 July 2013, Week 3 July 2013, Week 2 July 2013, Week 1 June 2013, Week 5 June 2013, Week 4 June 2013, Week 3 June 2013, Week 2 June 2013, Week 1 May 2013, Week 5 May 2013, Week 4 May 2013, Week 3 May 2013, Week 2 May 2013, Week 1 April 2013, Week 5 April 2013, Week 4 April 2013, Week 3 April 2013, Week 2 April 2013, Week 1 March 2013, Week 5 March 2013, Week 4 March 2013, Week 3 March 2013, Week 2 March 2013, Week 1 February 2013, Week 4 February 2013, Week 3 February 2013, Week 2 February 2013, Week 1 January 2013, Week 5 January 2013, Week 4 January 2013, Week 3 January 2013, Week 2 January 2013, Week 1 December 2012, Week 5 December 2012, Week 4 December 2012, Week 3 December 2012, Week 2 December 2012, Week 1 November 2012, Week 5 November 2012, Week 4 November 2012, Week 3 November 2012, Week 2 November 2012, Week 1 October 2012, Week 5 October 2012, Week 4 October 2012, Week 3 October 2012, Week 2 October 2012, Week 1 September 2012, Week 5 September 2012, Week 4 September 2012, Week 3 September 2012, Week 2 September 2012, Week 1 August 2012, Week 5 August 2012, Week 4 August 2012, Week 3 August 2012, Week 2 August 2012, Week 1 July 2012, Week 5 July 2012, Week 4 July 2012, Week 3 July 2012, Week 2 July 2012, Week 1 June 2012, Week 5 June 2012, Week 4 June 2012, Week 3 June 2012, Week 2 June 2012, Week 1 May 2012, Week 5 May 2012, Week 4 May 2012, Week 3 May 2012, Week 2 May 2012, Week 1 April 2012, Week 5 April 2012, Week 4 April 2012, Week 3 April 2012, Week 2 April 2012, Week 1 March 2012, Week 5 March 2012, Week 4 March 2012, Week 3 March 2012, Week 2 March 2012, Week 1 February 2012, Week 5 February 2012, Week 4 February 2012, Week 3 February 2012, Week 2 February 2012, Week 1 January 2012, Week 5 January 2012, Week 4 January 2012, Week 3 January 2012, Week 2 January 2012, Week 1 December 2011, Week 5 December 2011, Week 4 December 2011, Week 3 December 2011, Week 2 December 2011, Week 1 November 2011, Week 5 November 2011, Week 4 November 2011, Week 3 November 2011, Week 2 November 2011, Week 1 October 2011, Week 5 October 2011, Week 4 October 2011, Week 3 October 2011, Week 2 October 2011, Week 1 September 2011, Week 5 September 2011, Week 4 September 2011, Week 3 September 2011, Week 2 September 2011, Week 1 August 2011, Week 5 August 2011, Week 4 August 2011, Week 3 August 2011, Week 2 August 2011, Week 1 July 2011, Week 5 July 2011, Week 4 July 2011, Week 3 July 2011, Week 2 July 2011, Week 1 June 2011, Week 5 June 2011, Week 4 June 2011, Week 3 June 2011, Week 2 June 2011, Week 1 May 2011, Week 5 May 2011, Week 4 May 2011, Week 3 May 2011, Week 2 May 2011, Week 1 April 2011, Week 5 April 2011, Week 4 April 2011, Week 3 April 2011, Week 2 April 2011, Week 1 March 2011, Week 5 March 2011, Week 4 March 2011, Week 3 March 2011, Week 2 March 2011, Week 1 February 2011, Week 4 February 2011, Week 3 February 2011, Week 2 February 2011, Week 1 January 2011, Week 5 January 2011, Week 4 January 2011, Week 3 January 2011, Week 2 January 2011, Week 1 December 2010, Week 5 December 2010, Week 4 December 2010, Week 3 December 2010, Week 2 December 2010, Week 1 November 2010, Week 5 November 2010, Week 4 November 2010, Week 3 November 2010, Week 2 November 2010, Week 1 October 2010, Week 5 October 2010, Week 4 October 2010, Week 3 October 2010, Week 2 October 2010, Week 1 September 2010, Week 5 September 2010, Week 4 September 2010, Week 3 September 2010, Week 2 September 2010, Week 1 August 2010, Week 5 August 2010, Week 4 August 2010, Week 3 August 2010, Week 2 August 2010, Week 1 July 2010, Week 5 July 2010, Week 4 July 2010, Week 3 July 2010, Week 2 July 2010, Week 1 June 2010, Week 5 June 2010, Week 4 June 2010, Week 3 June 2010, Week 2 June 2010, Week 1 May 2010, Week 5 May 2010, Week 4 May 2010, Week 3 May 2010, Week 2 May 2010, Week 1 April 2010, Week 5 April 2010, Week 4 April 2010, Week 3 April 2010, Week 2 April 2010, Week 1 March 2010, Week 5 March 2010, Week 4 March 2010, Week 3 March 2010, Week 2 March 2010, Week 1 February 2010, Week 4 February 2010, Week 3 February 2010, Week 2 February 2010, Week 1 January 2010, Week 5 January 2010, Week 4 January 2010, Week 3 January 2010, Week 2 January 2010, Week 1 December 2009, Week 5 December 2009, Week 4 December 2009, Week 3 December 2009, Week 2 December 2009, Week 1 November 2009, Week 5 November 2009, Week 4 November 2009, Week 3 November 2009, Week 2 November 2009, Week 1 October 2009, Week 5 October 2009, Week 4 October 2009, Week 3 October 2009, Week 2 October 2009, Week 1 September 2009, Week 5 September 2009, Week 4 September 2009, Week 3 September 2009, Week 2 September 2009, Week 1 August 2009, Week 5 August 2009, Week 4 August 2009, Week 3 August 2009, Week 2 August 2009, Week 1 July 2009, Week 5 July 2009, Week 4 July 2009, Week 3 July 2009, Week 2 July 2009, Week 1 June 2009, Week 5 June 2009, Week 4 June 2009, Week 3 June 2009, Week 2 June 2009, Week 1 May 2009, Week 5 May 2009, Week 4 May 2009, Week 3 May 2009, Week 2 May 2009, Week 1 April 2009, Week 5 April 2009, Week 4 April 2009, Week 3 April 2009, Week 2 April 2009, Week 1 March 2009, Week 5 March 2009, Week 4 March 2009, Week 3 March 2009, Week 2 March 2009, Week 1 February 2009, Week 4 February 2009, Week 3 February 2009, Week 2 February 2009, Week 1 January 2009, Week 5 January 2009, Week 4 January 2009, Week 3 January 2009, Week 2 January 2009, Week 1 December 2008, Week 5 December 2008, Week 4 December 2008, Week 3 December 2008, Week 2 December 2008, Week 1 November 2008, Week 5 November 2008, Week 4 November 2008, Week 3 November 2008, Week 2 November 2008, Week 1 October 2008, Week 5 October 2008, Week 4 October 2008, Week 3 October 2008, Week 2 October 2008, Week 1 September 2008, Week 5 September 2008, Week 4 September 2008, Week 3 September 2008, Week 2 September 2008, Week 1 August 2008, Week 5 August 2008, Week 4 August 2008, Week 3 August 2008, Week 2 August 2008, Week 1 July 2008, Week 5 July 2008, Week 4 July 2008, Week 3 July 2008, Week 2 July 2008, Week 1 June 2008, Week 5 June 2008, Week 4 June 2008, Week 3 June 2008, Week 2 June 2008, Week 1 May 2008, Week 5 May 2008, Week 4 May 2008, Week 3 May 2008, Week 2 May 2008, Week 1 April 2008, Week 5 April 2008, Week 4 April 2008, Week 3 April 2008, Week 2 April 2008, Week 1 March 2008, Week 5 March 2008, Week 4 March 2008, Week 3 March 2008, Week 2 March 2008, Week 1 February 2008, Week 5 February 2008, Week 4 February 2008, Week 3 February 2008, Week 2 February 2008, Week 1 January 2008, Week 5 January 2008, Week 4 January 2008, Week 3 January 2008, Week 2 January 2008, Week 1 December 2007, Week 5 December 2007, Week 4 December 2007, Week 3 December 2007, Week 2 December 2007, Week 1 November 2007, Week 5 November 2007, Week 4 November 2007, Week 3 November 2007, Week 2 November 2007, Week 1 October 2007, Week 5 October 2007, Week 4 October 2007, Week 3 October 2007, Week 2 October 2007, Week 1 September 2007, Week 5 September 2007, Week 4 September 2007, Week 3 September 2007, Week 2 September 2007, Week 1 August 2007, Week 5 August 2007, Week 4 August 2007, Week 3 August 2007, Week 2 August 2007, Week 1 July 2007, Week 5 July 2007, Week 4 July 2007, Week 3 July 2007, Week 2 July 2007, Week 1 June 2007, Week 5 June 2007, Week 4 June 2007, Week 3 June 2007, Week 2 June 2007, Week 1 May 2007, Week 5 May 2007, Week 4 May 2007, Week 3 May 2007, Week 2 May 2007, Week 1 April 2007, Week 5 April 2007, Week 4 April 2007, Week 3 April 2007, Week 2 April 2007, Week 1 March 2007, Week 5 March 2007, Week 4 March 2007, Week 3 March 2007, Week 2 March 2007, Week 1 February 2007, Week 4 February 2007, Week 3 February 2007, Week 2 February 2007, Week 1 January 2007, Week 5 January 2007, Week 4 January 2007, Week 3 January 2007, Week 2 January 2007, Week 1 December 2006, Week 5 December 2006, Week 4 December 2006, Week 3 December 2006, Week 2 December 2006, Week 1 November 2006, Week 5 November 2006, Week 4 November 2006, Week 3 November 2006, Week 2 November 2006, Week 1 October 2006, Week 5 October 2006, Week 4 October 2006, Week 3 October 2006, Week 2 October 2006, Week 1 September 2006, Week 5 September 2006, Week 4 September 2006, Week 3 September 2006, Week 2 September 2006, Week 1 August 2006, Week 5 August 2006, Week 4 August 2006, Week 3 August 2006, Week 2 August 2006, Week 1 July 2006, Week 5 July 2006, Week 4 July 2006, Week 3 July 2006, Week 2 July 2006, Week 1 June 2006, Week 5 June 2006, Week 4 June 2006, Week 3 June 2006, Week 2 June 2006, Week 1 May 2006, Week 5 May 2006, Week 4 May 2006, Week 3 May 2006, Week 2 May 2006, Week 1 April 2006, Week 5 April 2006, Week 4 April 2006, Week 3 April 2006, Week 2 April 2006, Week 1 March 2006, Week 5 March 2006, Week 4 March 2006, Week 3 March 2006, Week 2 March 2006, Week 1 February 2006, Week 4 February 2006, Week 3 February 2006, Week 2 February 2006, Week 1 January 2006, Week 5 January 2006, Week 4 January 2006, Week 3 January 2006, Week 2 January 2006, Week 1 December 2005, Week 5 December 2005, Week 4 December 2005, Week 3 December 2005, Week 2 December 2005, Week 1 November 2005, Week 5 November 2005, Week 4 November 2005, Week 3 November 2005, Week 2 November 2005, Week 1 October 2005, Week 5 October 2005, Week 4 October 2005, Week 3 October 2005, Week 2 October 2005, Week 1 September 2005, Week 5 September 2005, Week 4 September 2005, Week 3 September 2005, Week 2 September 2005, Week 1 August 2005, Week 5 August 2005, Week 4 August 2005, Week 3 August 2005, Week 2 August 2005, Week 1 July 2005, Week 5 July 2005, Week 4 July 2005, Week 3 July 2005, Week 2 July 2005, Week 1 June 2005, Week 5 June 2005, Week 4 June 2005, Week 3 June 2005, Week 2 June 2005, Week 1 May 2005, Week 5 May 2005, Week 4 May 2005, Week 3 May 2005, Week 2 May 2005, Week 1 April 2005, Week 5 April 2005, Week 4 April 2005, Week 3 April 2005, Week 2 April 2005, Week 1 March 2005, Week 5 March 2005, Week 4 March 2005, Week 3 March 2005, Week 2 March 2005, Week 1 February 2005, Week 4 February 2005, Week 3 February 2005, Week 2 February 2005, Week 1 January 2005, Week 5 January 2005, Week 4 January 2005, Week 3 January 2005, Week 2 January 2005, Week 1 December 2004, Week 5 December 2004, Week 4 December 2004, Week 3 December 2004, Week 2 December 2004, Week 1 November 2004, Week 5 November 2004, Week 4 November 2004, Week 3 November 2004, Week 2 November 2004, Week 1 October 2004, Week 5 October 2004, Week 4 October 2004, Week 3 October 2004, Week 2 October 2004, Week 1 September 2004, Week 5 September 2004, Week 4 September 2004, Week 3 September 2004, Week 2 September 2004, Week 1 August 2004, Week 5 August 2004, Week 4 August 2004, Week 3 August 2004, Week 2 August 2004, Week 1 July 2004, Week 5 July 2004, Week 4 July 2004, Week 3 July 2004, Week 2 July 2004, Week 1 June 2004, Week 5 June 2004, Week 4 June 2004, Week 3 June 2004, Week 2 June 2004, Week 1 May 2004, Week 5 May 2004, Week 4 May 2004, Week 3 May 2004, Week 2 May 2004, Week 1 April 2004, Week 5 April 2004, Week 4 April 2004, Week 3 April 2004, Week 2 April 2004, Week 1 March 2004, Week 5 March 2004, Week 4 March 2004, Week 3 March 2004, Week 2 March 2004, Week 1 February 2004, Week 5 February 2004, Week 4 February 2004, Week 3 February 2004, Week 2 February 2004, Week 1 January 2004, Week 5 January 2004, Week 4 January 2004, Week 3 January 2004, Week 2 January 2004, Week 1 December 2003, Week 5 December 2003, Week 4 December 2003, Week 3 December 2003, Week 2 December 2003, Week 1 November 2003, Week 5 November 2003, Week 4 November 2003, Week 3 November 2003, Week 2 November 2003, Week 1 October 2003, Week 5 October 2003, Week 4 October 2003, Week 3 October 2003, Week 2 October 2003, Week 1 September 2003, Week 5 September 2003, Week 4 September 2003, Week 3 September 2003, Week 2 September 2003, Week 1 August 2003, Week 5 August 2003, Week 4 August 2003, Week 3 August 2003, Week 2 August 2003, Week 1 July 2003, Week 5 July 2003, Week 4 July 2003, Week 3 July 2003, Week 2 July 2003, Week 1 June 2003, Week 5 June 2003, Week 4 June 2003, Week 3 June 2003, Week 2 June 2003, Week 1 May 2003, Week 5 May 2003, Week 4 May 2003, Week 3 May 2003, Week 2 May 2003, Week 1 April 2003, Week 5 April 2003, Week 4 April 2003, Week 3 April 2003, Week 2 April 2003, Week 1 March 2003, Week 5 March 2003, Week 4 March 2003, Week 3 March 2003, Week 2 March 2003, Week 1 February 2003, Week 4 February 2003, Week 3 February 2003, Week 2 February 2003, Week 1 January 2003, Week 5 January 2003, Week 4 January 2003, Week 3 January 2003, Week 2 January 2003, Week 1 December 2002, Week 5 December 2002, Week 4 December 2002, Week 3 December 2002, Week 2 December 2002, Week 1 November 2002, Week 5 November 2002, Week 4 November 2002, Week 3 November 2002, Week 2 November 2002, Week 1 October 2002, Week 5 October 2002, Week 4 October 2002, Week 3 October 2002, Week 2 October 2002, Week 1 September 2002, Week 5 September 2002, Week 4 September 2002, Week 3 September 2002, Week 2 September 2002, Week 1 August 2002, Week 5 August 2002, Week 4 August 2002, Week 3 August 2002, Week 2 August 2002, Week 1 July 2002, Week 5 July 2002, Week 4 July 2002, Week 3 July 2002, Week 2 July 2002, Week 1 June 2002, Week 5 June 2002, Week 4 June 2002, Week 3 June 2002, Week 2 June 2002, Week 1 May 2002, Week 5 May 2002, Week 4 May 2002, Week 3 May 2002, Week 2 May 2002, Week 1 April 2002, Week 5 April 2002, Week 4 April 2002, Week 3 April 2002, Week 2 April 2002, Week 1 March 2002, Week 5 March 2002, Week 4 March 2002, Week 3 March 2002, Week 2 March 2002, Week 1 February 2002, Week 4 February 2002, Week 3 February 2002, Week 2 February 2002, Week 1 January 2002, Week 5 January 2002, Week 4 January 2002, Week 3 January 2002, Week 2 January 2002, Week 1 December 2001, Week 5 December 2001, Week 4 December 2001, Week 3 December 2001, Week 2 December 2001, Week 1 November 2001, Week 5 November 2001, Week 4 November 2001, Week 3 November 2001, Week 2 November 2001, Week 1 October 2001, Week 5 October 2001, Week 4 October 2001, Week 3 October 2001, Week 2 October 2001, Week 1 September 2001, Week 5 September 2001, Week 4 September 2001, Week 3 September 2001, Week 2 September 2001, Week 1 August 2001, Week 5 August 2001, Week 4 August 2001, Week 3 August 2001, Week 2 August 2001, Week 1 July 2001, Week 5 July 2001, Week 4 July 2001, Week 3 July 2001, Week 2 July 2001, Week 1 June 2001, Week 5 June 2001, Week 4 June 2001, Week 3 June 2001, Week 2 June 2001, Week 1 May 2001, Week 5 May 2001, Week 4 May 2001, Week 3 May 2001, Week 2 May 2001, Week 1 April 2001, Week 5 April 2001, Week 4 April 2001, Week 3 April 2001, Week 2 April 2001, Week 1 March 2001, Week 5 March 2001, Week 4 March 2001, Week 3 March 2001, Week 2 March 2001, Week 1 February 2001, Week 4 February 2001, Week 3 February 2001, Week 2 February 2001, Week 1 January 2001, Week 5 January 2001, Week 4 January 2001, Week 3 January 2001, Week 2 January 2001, Week 1 December 2000, Week 5 December 2000, Week 4 December 2000, Week 3 December 2000, Week 2 December 2000, Week 1 November 2000, Week 5 November 2000, Week 4 November 2000, Week 3 November 2000, Week 2 November 2000, Week 1 October 2000, Week 5 October 2000, Week 4 October 2000, Week 3 October 2000, Week 2 October 2000, Week 1 September 2000, Week 5 September 2000, Week 4 September 2000, Week 3 September 2000, Week 2 September 2000, Week 1 August 2000, Week 5 August 2000, Week 4 August 2000, Week 3 August 2000, Week 2 August 2000, Week 1 July 2000, Week 5 July 2000, Week 4 July 2000, Week 3 July 2000, Week 2 July 2000, Week 1 June 2000, Week 5 June 2000, Week 4 June 2000, Week 3 June 2000, Week 2 June 2000, Week 1 May 2000, Week 5 May 2000, Week 4 May 2000, Week 3 May 2000, Week 2 May 2000, Week 1 April 2000, Week 5 April 2000, Week 4 April 2000, Week 3 April 2000, Week 2 April 2000, Week 1 March 2000, Week 5 March 2000, Week 4 March 2000, Week 3 March 2000, Week 2 March 2000, Week 1 February 2000, Week 5 February 2000, Week 4 February 2000, Week 3 February 2000, Week 2 February 2000, Week 1 January 2000, Week 5 January 2000, Week 4 January 2000, Week 3 January 2000, Week 2 January 2000, Week 1 December 1999, Week 5 December 1999, Week 4 December 1999, Week 3 December 1999, Week 2 December 1999, Week 1 November 1999, Week 5 November 1999, Week 4 November 1999, Week 3 November 1999, Week 2 November 1999, Week 1 October 1999, Week 5 October 1999, Week 4 October 1999, Week 3 October 1999, Week 2 October 1999, Week 1 September 1999, Week 5 September 1999, Week 4 September 1999, Week 3 September 1999, Week 2 September 1999, Week 1 August 1999, Week 5 August 1999, Week 4 August 1999, Week 3 August 1999, Week 2 August 1999, Week 1 July 1999, Week 5 July 1999, Week 4 July 1999, Week 3 July 1999, Week 2 July 1999, Week 1 June 1999, Week 5 June 1999, Week 4 June 1999, Week 3 June 1999, Week 2 June 1999, Week 1 May 1999, Week 5 May 1999, Week 4 May 1999, Week 3 May 1999, Week 2 May 1999, Week 1 April 1999, Week 5 April 1999, Week 4 April 1999, Week 3 April 1999, Week 2 April 1999, Week 1 March 1999, Week 5 March 1999, Week 4 March 1999, Week 3 March 1999, Week 2 March 1999, Week 1 February 1999, Week 5 February 1999, Week 4 February 1999, Week 3 February 1999, Week 2 February 1999, Week 1 January 1999, Week 5 January 1999, Week 4 January 1999, Week 3 January 1999, Week 2 January 1999, Week 1 December 1998, Week 5 December 1998, Week 4 December 1998, Week 3 December 1998, Week 2 December 1998, Week 1 November 1998, Week 5 November 1998, Week 4 November 1998, Week 3 November 1998, Week 2 November 1998, Week 1 October 1998, Week 5 October 1998, Week 4 October 1998, Week 3 October 1998, Week 2 October 1998, Week 1 September 1998, Week 5 September 1998, Week 4 September 1998, Week 3
|
|
|
|