Could you explain why you need the surrounding element at all? In the example that you give, the seg just surrounds a single p. Couldn't you have the ana-attribute on the p element and not have a seg at all?
> -----Original Message-----
> From: TEI (Text Encoding Initiative) public discussion list [mailto:TEI-
> [log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Rosanna Cantavella
> Sent: Tuesday, May 19, 2015 7:18 PM
> To: [log in to unmask]
> Subject: [TEI-L] <div> or <seg>?
> Dear all,
> I'm marking up a series of medieval troubadour poetry handbooks, in order
> to localize and classify all different definitions and types of rhyme according
> to this cultural tradition. I am not transcribing directly from the manuscripts
> (often preserved in numerous witnesses), but from their modern editions;
> and not marking these works in their entirety, but only those parts in which
> definitions of rhyme are given in each text.
> I'm using <div> to enclose each fragment of text in which these definitions
> appear inside a given work. These fragments are in some cases as short as a
> paragraph, and in others as long as a chapter would be in a modern work. I
> usually have no more than two or three divs for each work: <div n= “1”>, <div
> n= “2”> etc.
> Now my question: within each <div> I usually find definitions of several types
> of rhyme, which I'll duly mark up individually with @ana attributes (thanks
> again, Lou!). But what element would you recommend for these arbitrary
> (that is, created by me and not by the author) chunks of text inside each
> a) Again <div>? (But how should I differentiate the enclosing divs from these
> b) Switch to <seg>? (But I've only seen very short <seg> examples. I have to
> enclose sometimes several paragraphs in one definition. Can <seg> enclose
> whole paragraphs? And would <seg ana= “#A1”>, <seg ana= “#C3”> etc. be a
> correct markup?)
> Hypothetical example:
> <div n= “1”> Bla bla bla … bla bla
> <seg ana= “#C3”><p>DELS RIMS UTRISSONANS. Rim utrissonan son dig can la
> vocals muda lo significat de la dictio. mudan lo so plenissonan. en so.
> semissonan. o pel contrari. segon. quom pot ayssi vezer.
> <l>Sias tempratz e gent apres. </l>
> <l>En tas paraulas et apres. </l>
> <l>Si fas de compas e de pes. </l>
> <l>Sas obras remandran enpes.</l>
> <p>Bla bla bla...</p></div>
> As you can see, not every line of text inside every div refers to definitions,
> and therefore not every line or paragraph would be enclosed by <seg> or by
> these 'sub-divs'.
> Thank you in advance,
> Prof. Rosanna Cantavella
> Universitat de València / Clare Hall, University of Cambridge