Print

Print


> [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of steve rice


> > If someone wants to see bashing, go here:
> > 
> > 	http://www.xibalba.demon.co.uk/jbr/ranto/
> > 
> > And as harsh as the author's attach on E-o is, every point made
is a
> > valid criticism of E-o, offering us all a lesson to learn from
in
> > devising future auxlangs.
> 
> "Every" point? I'm not reflexively pro-Eo, believe it
> or not, and I see a number of places where his rabies
> is talking, not his brain. I'm reminded of C. S.
> Lewis' remark about critics who claim to have seen
> through what they haven't even seen. 

I said it's a bit harsh, and does fail to give credit where it's
due, but I can't see anything there I really disagree with.  He does
title it "Ranto" so we know what to expect.  FWIW: I have exchanged
a few private e-mails with Justin Rye after seeing that site a few
times.