I'm confused by this comment. Neither tei:facsimile nor support or zone 
can take tei:figure, as far as I can see, only tei:graphic.

In any case, tei:desc inside graphic surely describes the image pointed 
to by that graphic, "including its intended usage, purpose, or 
application", which is surely not so far off what you'd want to put in a 
caption. (And indeed the content model of tei:desc includes elements 
such as bibl, cit, and the like which could be used to document the 
origin, ownership, and other information about the image (precisely what 
you might want in a caption).

But I'm keen not to commit tag-abuse, so if desc on tei:graphic should 
*only* be used for technical description of the image (rather than 
public-facing prose + a reference, say), then how do I get tei:figure 
into the facsimile section?


On 06/01/2011 20:09, Lou Burnard wrote:
> <desc>  isn't really meant to hold a caption, but rather a description of
> the object. If you need a caption, I'd suggest using<figure>.
> On 06/01/11 19:09, Mylonas, Elli wrote:
>> I found<desc>   to be useful for the image caption. something like
>> "Page 2" or "lower left hand corner." But maybe that just means that
>> this is a job for<figure>?
>> On Thu, Jan 6, 2011 at 1:55 PM, Lou Burnard
>> <[log in to unmask]>   wrote:
>>> Good question. There's an example showing that we ought to have thought
>>> of this before (the example showing high res and low res versions of the
>>> same surface)...
>>> I think the grouping is done solely by<surface>   -- all the graphicLike
>>> children of a given surface or zone are understood to be alternative
>>> versions of it. However, you can now add a<desc>   child to your
>>> <graphic>   to document it. (Or use<figure>   rather than<graphic>, if you
>>> have a more complex multipart graphic).
>>> So we should probably revise the existing example to say something like
>>> <facsimile>
>>>    <graphic url="page1.png"/>
>>>    <surface>
>>>     <graphic url="page2-highRes.png">
>>>          <desc>High resolution image</desc>
>>>     </graphic>
>>>     <graphic url="page2-lowRes.png">
>>> <desc>Low resolution image</desc>
>>> </graphic>
>>>    </surface>
>>>    <graphic url="page3.png"/>
>>>    <graphic url="page4.png"/>
>>> </facsimile>
>>>    On 06/01/11 18:28, Gabriel Bodard wrote:
>>>> Does anyone have any suggestions for how to distinguish different kinds
>>>> of images of the same surface in the facsimile section?
>>>> In particular, I may have two images of the same surface or zone, one of
>>>> which is a digital photo graph (or scan of an analogue photo) and the
>>>> other is the scan of a 17th century drawing (which may be a better
>>>> representation [of the original] than the modern photograph, because of
>>>> damage etc.). For different processes I may want to make available to
>>>> the user one or other of these types of facsimile.
>>>> Typing the tei:graphic elements would be the obvious possibility (except
>>>> @type isn't available on tei:graphic), since the various grouping
>>>> elements available here (tei:zone, tei:surface) have different
>>>> semantics, and the two images may well be of the same surface and zone.
>>>> Any thoughts?
>>>> G

Dr Gabriel BODARD
(Research Associate in Digital Epigraphy)

Centre for Computing in the Humanities
King's College London
26-29 Drury Lane
London WC2B 5RL
Email: [log in to unmask]
Tel: +44 (0)20 7848 1388
Fax: +44 (0)20 7848 2980