Very good point, and I too wondered about the various tags available for performance. (I leave it to theorists and specialists in both liturgy and drama to deal with whether this reduces one cultural and literary form into a subset of the other ....) 

I wrote the note in ignorance of the larger schema-framework the encoders are using. I suspect that since they are encoding from manuscript that semantic tagging of content may take a back seat to primary source description. But implicit in your question (and correctly!) is precisely the question of the larger conceptualization of the project.

HL



On 4/3/2017 2:21 PM, Lou Burnard wrote:
[log in to unmask]" type="cite">
Well, yes, <seg> CAN be used like that, to cover all sorts of edge cases. (Though you may find it needs to be wrapped up in a <p> or something similar).
But if you;re interested in marking up the liturgy semantically, why not do the job properly, using <sp> and <p> and <lg> for the various scripted parts, and <stage> for the "directions" ? Alternatively, you could use <note>, perhaps with a @type attribute to indicate that it's an instruction. Either of these options has the advantage that it can appear within or between paragraphs.



On 03/04/17 16:57, Hayim Lapin wrote:
[log in to unmask]" type="cite">

Hello all,

A colleague working on liturgical texts (in fact, seasonably appropriate: the text for the passover seder) asked how her group might encode liturgical instructions ("here the cup is raised"; "In X circumstances the following is recited").

I suggested <seg> using @type and @subtype attributes as necessary to specify further.  However, my guess is that there are people on this list who have far more experience than me with this sort of thing.

Any suggestions?
Many thanks,
-- 
Hayim Lapin
Professor of History
Robert H. Smith Professor of Jewish Studies
2115 Francis Scott Key Hall
College Park, MD 20190
+1 301 405 4296
www.digitalmishnah.umd.edu | www.erabbinica.org



-- 
Hayim Lapin
Professor of History
Robert H. Smith Professor of Jewish Studies
2115 Francis Scott Key Hall
College Park, MD 20190
+1 301 405 4296
www.digitalmishnah.umd.edu | www.erabbinica.org